Have a rabid Sesame Street fan in your house? (I mean “rabid” in the nicest possible doesn’t-actually-have-rabies kind of way, of course.) Right now Amazon is running a 30% off deal on Sesame Street Gund plush toys: Buy any two, and they’ll be 30% off at checkout.
This is particularly nice because several are already marked down. This Grover, for example, is almost $10 (looks to be around $14 everywhere else), so he’d only be $7; and this fairy-in-training Abby Cadabby is $12 (goes for at least $20 elsewhere), so she’d only be $8.
These aren’t just the characters your kids love, they’re from Gund, so they should be pretty high-quality items. Plus I feel certain that someone on your list is in need of a plush Oscar the Grouch.